Monday, March 11, 2019

Blurt, Blush, Apologize......Repeat

Friday, I grabbed the first laugh-o-dills of the season. I love the moment I first spy them in the big green container, their hysterically yellow petals still hidden within brown, papery sheaths. Put them in water and wait for the miracle of color explosion. The room becomes touched with the scent of sunshine even if the the snow is still piled a foot high on the deck. Suddenly, spring doesn't seem so out of reach.

But outside, the beautiful white fluff is already melting into grey slush, the kind that freezes at night and melts in the afternoon, insuring that morning is a treacherous event. Despite the astoundingly blue sky that frames cotton covered branches, there is more snow on the ground than is manageable. There is so much snow, people are trying to mitigate melting around foundations by digging trenches wherever they can, and removing snow from roofs before the bulging begins. 

I suppose that could be a metaphor for a lotta things. Beauty, while in the eye of the beholder, can mean different things in many different eyes, just like words can be heard by millions of ears and result in just as many interpretations. There is, however, the tiny little matter of intentionality. If you say something untoward and people tell you that your remarks are rude/cruel/inappropriate/racist or whatever, you get to have a eureka moment followed by a whole lotta work to improve your communication skills. Assuming your intention was not to be rude/cruel/inappropriate/racist or whatever, your focus has to be on how to get a point across without being a total nitwit. This sounds a  whole lot easier than it really is. Most people fail miserably and continue to sound like total nitwits. They are unable or unwilling to do the work needed to sound less .....whatever. 

Communication requires real work. Our tendency is to forget that what comes out of our mouths doesn't necessarily match what our brains intended. Oh, you know the drill: blurt, blush, apologize. 

But that's not what I'm really thinking about. I'm thinking about when what you say is really what you mean, even though you do the blurt, blush, apologize routing. Multiple times. You continue to utter phrases and expressions that are rude/cruel/inappropriate/racist or whatever....and then plead, oh, any number of excuses: I didn't know.....I was really criticizing something else.....I meant it for other people not you..... I bet you know that drill, too. And you know it because you know that person meant exactly what he or she said. 

The Sabbath Year Float
At carnival in Belgium last week, the town of Aalst featured some pretty horrific floats with cartoon puppets worthy of 1932 Germany....and those images were defended by the mayor who said, 
But Mayor D’Haese told Het Laatste Nieuws that “it’s not up to the mayor to forbid” such displays, and that “the carnival participants had no sinister intentions.     Ha'Aretz - 03/06/2019                               
Can one assume this was all in fun? Was it meant to be a joke? Was the antisemitic image meant to be something to be laughed at? If those puppets had been Little Black Sambo would the mayor have defended them as simple, harmless, little jokey things? 

I want to believe antisemitism is a function of ignorance, (although I'm beginning to doubt that, too.) When antisemitism parades as anti-Zionism, there needs to be acknowledgement of reality. To be sure, there is much to criticize about Netanyahu and his government, but one cannot call Israel apartheid when Arab nations do not permit non-Muslims equal rights and protections within those countries. You can criticize Israel for human rights abuses, but you cannot ignore LGBT men and women being sentenced to death in Iran, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, United Arab Emirates, or Yemen. You cannot talk about Nakba without recognizing that 900,000 Jews were expelled from Arab countries in the 1940s with nowhere to go. In other words, you cannot pick and choose which horrors are to be condemned. Condemn one, you must actively condemn the others, lest you be identified as the anti-Semite you really are. 

And you cannot ignore that which is taking root here. Antisemitism has increased dramatically in the last few years. And despite the words occasionally falling out of Feckless Leader's mouth, it's clear to most of the world that the man is both a racist and an antisemite. Why is it so hard for a large swath of Americans to understand that, as well as understand the long-term implications?

Someone once said it doesn't matter whether or not you're an antisemite if the antisemites think you are. David Duke is busy praising Ilhan Omar for her statements, and who is a bigger, publicly avowed antisemite than David Duke? Being supported by David Duke is troubling on a whole bunch of disparate levels. 

I sound like a broken record to even me these days, but the news is increasingly filled with images and statements that make my blood run cold in my veins. Despite it all, I want to believe America will arise above this heinous fray, but I'm not as sure as I once was. The closer we move to 2020, the more I suspect we are heading toward civil war. And just as history has demonstrated again and again, the Jews will be caught in the middle.

And here's the really scary part: if Netanyhu continues on as Prime Minister, we may not have an Israel to go to if push comes to shove. Think about that for a moment.

The Wifely Person's Tip o'the Week

Daffodils are really inexpensive. 
Treat yourself. 

4 comments:

  1. Fascinating article and I appreciate the juxtaposition of the bright, sunny, yellow flowers with the horrendous 'flot' in the Belgian parade :(

    ReplyDelete
  2. “Condemn one, you must actively condemn the others, lest you be identified as the anti-Semite you really are.“
    By this, do you mean that anyone condemning antisemitism and not actively condemning racism, the murder of Black youth by agents of the state, systemic bias that impedes the health and well-being of the communities of people of color should be labeled racist and a supporter of systemic bias?

    Also, who exactly determines what and how activivism is “active” enough?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pretty much, yes. I may have been writing specifically about antisemitism here, but the premise must apply to all marginalized, harassed, ignored, or persecuted people....and that would most definitely includes the indigenous peoples of the United States who are the most marginalized of all.

      The sad thing about anti-semitism is that we have a recent event to serve as a process marker. The Jews of Germany believed it was going to all go away, but it didn’t. So the anti-Semitic trope really is a dog whistle for those who would see us exterminated, and a warning bell for us.

      Nice Germans closed their curtains and said nothing as their neighbors were rounded up. They were inactive. If we stand together against the anti-isms, we have a fighting chance of saving lives. Active is not sitting down. If enough people refuse to stand down, more people will be willing to join the fight. I hope.

      Delete
  3. Crackpot (and goes without saying Big Donald
    supporter) thinks
    having Hearings on TheCorruption of Donald is somehow,
    "treason."

    No, if anything Treason was throwing US Intelligence
    UnderTheBus to Appease Putin.


    USA uS AMerica NewHampshire

    ReplyDelete